Menu

Photo by Nicholas Donner Photo by Nicholas Donner


Cookies

  • Views:
  • Chocolate Chip

    This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years.

  • Snickerdoodle

    Guaranteed to take you back to childhood with one bite. Our snickerdoodles are buttery, tender, and rolled in cinnamon sugar, just like Mom did.

  • Nutella

    5kg of Nutella in every batch, hazelnut extract, Dutch cocoa powder…these are the ultimate chocolate hazelnut indulgence!

  • Peanut Butter

    Our special twist on the classic peanut butter – it’s gooey, with honey vanilla notes, and chock full of peanut butter!

  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

    The classic. Chewy oats with just the right level of spice and a generous helping of plump raisins.

  • Ginger Molasses

    Chewy, puffy cookies with dark molasses flavor, spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and lots of ginger. Crowned with sugar for a crispy crust!

  • Vegan Chocolate Chip

    The Captain churns our vegan butter from scratch – these cookies are a three-day process, and their amazing taste is the result of years of recipe-tweaking!

Ice-Cream

  • Views:
  • Vanilla Ice Cream

    From a local creamery, by the scoop!

  • Chocolate Ice Cream

    From a local creamery, by the scoop!

  • Black Cherry Ice Cream

    From a local creamery, by the scoop!

Milk

  • Views:
  • 2% Milk

    Local Creamery Milk. Price per bottle. Local pickup/delivery only.

  • Skim Milk

    12 ounces. Local Creamery Milk. Price per bottle. Local pickup/delivery only.

  • Chocolate Milk

    12 ounces. Local Creamery Milk. Price per bottle. Local pickup/delivery only.

  • Whole Milk

    There's nothing like full-flavored, local whole milk!

  • Soy Milk

    Not quite local, but darn refreshing, and vegan/vegetarian! Take one with two vegan cookies.

Specials

  • Views:
  • Baker's Dozen

    13 cookies at a bargain price. Specify your cookie selection in the comments section during checkout.

  • Chipwich

    Pick any two cookies and ice cream! Local pickup/delivery only.

  • Cookie Cake - Regular - 14"

    A giant version of our classic cookie (any flavor!), hand-decorated to order with delicious cream cheese icing. Serves 12-15! Please allow several hours for us to bake, cool, and decorate your cake to order!

  • Cookie Cake - Large - 16"-18"

    A giant version of our classic cookie (any flavor!), hand-decorated to order with delicious cream cheese icing. Serves 20-25! Please allow several hours for us to bake, cool, and decorate this item to order.

  • 1/2 Dozen

    6 cookies. Please specify your cookie selection in the comments section during checkout.

  • Milk and Cookies

    One bottle of milk plus two cookies of your choice. Specify your milk and cookie selection in the comments section during checkout.

Merchandise

No products were found.

Delivery

DC-wide Same-Day Cookie Delivery! Monday-Friday, 10am-4pm; Saturday 11am-4pm

We deliver cookies & milk anywhere in DC and to parts of Arlington with no minimum purchase, for only $10 (delivery fee). Send your friends, business partners or loved ones any selection of cookies, milk, and/or personalized cookie cakes — or treat yourself! 24 hours’ notice is needed for large deliveries. For smaller deliveries, same-day orders can be accommodated if placed before 9:30am (delivered by 2pm) and 1:30pm (delivered by 4pm).

Delivery after 4pm is available through our delivery partners Foodler, Postmates, and the Uber Eats app!